Muscle Soreness – “Must-Have” or “No-Go” in Training
14 Min
Laktat, Mythen und Studien: Wie Muskelkater wirklich entsteht, ob Du mit Muskelkater trainieren darfst und wann er Dir als Gradmesser dienen kann.
Dear BLOG readers, Dear PEAK customers,
We’ve all experienced it—THAT MUSCLE SORENESS!
As a bodybuilder, you learn to live with muscle soreness. For many, it’s a sign of a “good” workout. Others claim that muscle soreness is a sign of muscle loss. There are also some pretty funny rumors about what causes muscle soreness, such as the theory that it’s caused by a buildup of lactate in the muscles.
The fact is:
All of us have experienced muscle soreness at least once in our lives; many deal with it regularly or even set it as a goal. Very few people know exactly where it comes from or how to interpret it.
So today, I’d like to address these very questions and, in doing so, critically examine some myths in the world of bodybuilding.
Outdated Theory – What Is Sore Muscle?
It used to be assumed that muscle soreness resulted from a buildup of lactate in the muscles. Lactate is a metabolic byproduct of the muscles that is produced during anaerobic exercise. Lactate is the reason why a state of acidosis develops in the muscles, which is associated with a decline in performance.
Based on current scientific understanding, the theory that lactate is responsible for muscle soreness must be unequivocally refuted. The fact is that, depending on the individual, muscle soreness does not occur until 1–2 days after exercise. However, lactate is cleared from the body within the first hour after training and is thus one of the body’s first regenerative processes, since enzymatic processes can only function optimally at a specific pH level.
There is therefore no temporal correlation here.
Conclusion
Lactate accumulation and muscle soreness are not related to one another.
A Brief Digression—The Structure of Our Muscles
Before we delve into the correct theory regarding the development of muscle soreness, I’d like to provide all readers with some basic knowledge about muscles.
General Structure of a Muscle
The smallest unit of a muscle is the muscle fiber (see below). Several muscle fibers form a muscle fiber bundle. The “perimysium” refers to the sheath surrounding a muscle fiber bundle. All muscle fiber bundles within a muscle are enclosed by the so-called “epimysium.” Both are connective-tissue-like structures that provide support to the muscle fiber bundle. The muscle derives its outer shape from the so-called muscle fascia, another strong sheath.
Every muscle has blood vessels and nerves that supply it and enable communication with the outside world. The incoming vessels branch out into a network of capillaries that supplies each muscle fiber individually. The removal of waste products is organized accordingly. In addition to its blood supply, each muscle fiber also has its own nerve. Together with the nerve, it forms what is known as a motor unit.

Illustration: Structure of the Muscle
The Muscle Fiber
Components of a muscle fiber
A muscle fiber consists of 75% water. Proteins account for 20%, while 5% consists of fat, glycogen, nitrogen-containing substances, and ions (potassium, sodium, magnesium, calcium, chloride). The protein fraction must be further divided into structural proteins (70%) and soluble proteins (30%). 50% of the structural proteins consist of contractile proteins (myosin and actin), while 20% are accounted for by the stroma (saline solutions, protein residues, and ground substance).
The muscle fiber is a structure composed of water, protein, and fat.
Structure of a Muscle Fiber
A muscle fiber (also called a striated muscle cell) develops from myoblasts (the precursor cells of muscle cells), which fuse together to form a filamentous structure. A 1-mm muscle fiber can contain up to 40 cell nuclei. A muscle fiber is between 1 mm and 15 cm long and has a diameter of 10–200 micrometers.
Inside the muscle fiber are structures called myofibrils. These can be described as individual functional, longitudinally oriented, elongated filaments within the muscle fiber, which in turn are divided into individual functional segments called sarcomeres. Z-lines separate the individual sarcomeres from one another.
Interesting
The myofibril also contains mitochondria. They are responsible for supplying energy to the unit.

Illustration: Muscle Fiber Structure
Structure of a sarcomere
Actin filaments and myosin filaments are the components within the sarcomere responsible for muscle contraction. Actin filaments are thin filaments that extend from the Z-band (the walls of the sarcomere) toward the center of the sarcomere. Myosin filaments are located in the center of the sarcomere and can form a direct connection with actin filaments during contraction. At rest, they do not touch each other. Only during contraction do the heads of the myosin filaments hook onto the actin filaments and pull them together, causing the muscle to shorten.
All components of the sarcomere are enclosed by the sarcolemma.

Illustration: Sarcomere
This is intended to provide a brief insight into the structure and function of our muscles, to help you better understand the following description of how muscle soreness actually develops.
Valid Hypothesis – What Is Sore Muscle?
The term “muscle soreness”
“Sore muscles” is a term that has emerged from common parlance.
It describes a condition that usually occurs after an unusual or very intense physical exertion and signals that the affected muscle has been overworked. Sore muscles typically appear within the first two days after exertion, peak after about two days, and then subside.
Symptoms
Sore muscles are characterized by stiffness or tension in the muscles, increased sensitivity to touch, and pain during movement, especially during physical activity. Physical performance is reduced during an acute episode of muscle soreness.
Cause
Overuse caused by exercise leads to damage to muscular structures. This damage (primarily to the so-called Z-lines) impairs contractile function.
Interesting
Inexperienced athletes, in particular, often struggle with muscle soreness.
What happens?
Eccentric exercise
Especially during eccentric contraction (tensing the muscle while it is in a stretched state), the muscle filaments are pulled apart or torn despite shortening.
This results in opposing tensile forces acting on the myosin heads on both sides of the Z-lines. These myosin heads attempt to perform their shortening work (contraction) despite the high external forces.
The result of these opposing forces is widened or torn Z-lines.
The Z-bands of a sarcomere represent the weakest link in the chain.
This damage causes swelling to develop as part of the inflammatory response within the muscle cell. The swelling presses on the fine nerve fibers in the surrounding connective tissue, thereby causing the pain symptoms. In addition, so-called inflammatory mediators—substances that trigger inflammation—are released in the microtraumatized muscle, which also contribute to the typical pain symptoms of muscle soreness.
Interesting
Eccentric muscle work, in particular, tends to cause muscle soreness!
Interesting
Given the many processes involved in their development, it is possible to explain the time lag before muscle soreness sets in.
Intense exercise
Both the intensity and duration of muscular exertion can trigger muscle soreness. High-intensity exercise results in more severe muscle soreness than exercise of longer duration.
Intensity is more likely to damage the muscle than a long duration of exercise!
Muscle Soreness and Muscle Fiber Types
The degree of damage varies among the different muscle fiber types. Slow-twitch (ST) fibers, which are primarily responsible for endurance performance, have wider Z-lines and are therefore less susceptible to the development of muscle soreness. Fast FT fibers (fast-twitch fibers), which contract rapidly and are responsible for explosive power, have weaker connections between their contractile units and are therefore more susceptible to muscle soreness.
Interesting
Muscle soreness occurs primarily during unfamiliar, intense, and eccentric exercises!
Does it make sense to train with sore muscles?
Two myths circulate in the world of bodybuilding:
Myth 1: If you have severe muscle soreness, you absolutely must do another hard
workout.
Myth 2: You shouldn’t train a muscle again until the soreness
has completely subsided.
The truth lies somewhere in between, as the following study results are intended to demonstrate:
Study 1
As a Japanese study found, a workout performed 2 days after a session that caused muscle soreness—and targeting the same muscle group—results in lower overall cortisol production than if there were a 4-day break between the two workouts.
The lower cortisol levels allow for higher concentrations of anabolic hormones, such as testosterone. These hormones stimulate growth more effectively.
No significant changes were observed between the experimental groups in terms of maximum strength, range of motion, or plasma creatine kinase (a marker of muscle damage), which means that muscle damage did not worsen even after just a 2-day break
Taking just a 2-day break after a workout that causes muscle soreness before the next workout is not a disadvantage!
Study 2
An Australian study compared the recovery times following an eccentric biceps workout, either performed alone (once a week) or with two training sessions within three days. At the time of the second eccentric workout, the participants still had muscle soreness; however, recovery ultimately proceeded just as quickly as in the group that did only one workout. Since more weight was lifted overall during the two-workout regimen, greater muscle growth also occurred in this group.
Despite only a 2-day rest period, there was no delay in recovery—and greater gains in terms of hypertrophy!
Study 3
Another study examined the effects of eccentric training with varying training frequency, intensity, and volume on the muscles. In 6 groups, 30, 50, and 70 repetitions of an arm curl were performed either once a week or twice a week (with a 3-day rest period).
Results
In all groups, a higher number of microtraumas was observed due to the unfamiliar eccentric load. There were no significant differences among the various training intervals.
The maximum possible elbow angle (CIR) increased throughout the study in parallel with the number of repetitions. Only the group performing 30 repetitions showed no change.
Typical sensitivity reactions associated with muscle soreness occurred in all participants and peaked between Day 1 and Day 3 after Workout 1.
The number of repetitions played no role here.
Serum creatine kinase and myoglobin concentrations increased, peaking 4–6 days after Workout 1 and continuing to rise until the 10th day. Serum NO concentrations increased on days 1–4 after Workout 1. The increase stopped after Workout 2.
No differences were observed with regard to different repetition counts
The second workout, performed 3 days later, had no effect on recovery. Repeated eccentric training does not result in excessive muscle damage, even if the second workout involves a higher volume or intensity.
It appears that the recovery of our muscles is not affected by a subsequent workout, regardless of how intense or voluminous it is. As early as 3 days after a workout, the muscles seem to be elastic enough for another workout.
Conclusion
The body generally needs 48–72 hours to recover between workouts. At the latest after this time—but actually as early as 48 hours—another workout can be performed, regardless of whether muscle soreness is still present or not.
Myth 2 has thus been debunked!!
Is muscle soreness generally beneficial?
Chronic muscle soreness
If muscles are constantly overloaded to the point of severe soreness, it can lead to scarring and impaired function. People who experience constant muscle soreness risk impaired recovery and, consequently, reduced muscle growth, as well as insulin resistance in muscle cells, which significantly hinders nutrient transport.
Extreme muscle soreness
Extreme muscle soreness—by which I mean severe pain lasting several days and significant limitations in mobility—is also not effective for training when experienced over the long term and on a permanent basis. Through the pain, the muscle signals that it has been heavily strained and needs a break.
If this condition persists, it also leads to the disadvantages mentioned above, which have a “hypertrophy-stagnating” effect.
Severe muscle soreness is not an indication of an optimal subthreshold training stimulus (optimal hypertrophy effect), but rather an indication of a significantly suprathreshold training stimulus, which tends to have counterproductive effects.
Myth 1 is thus debunked!!
What does the practitioner say?
From a practical perspective and based on 16 years of training experience, I can say that there is indeed such a thing as “optimal muscle soreness.” It manifests as a slight pulling sensation in the muscle on the first, second, and perhaps even third day after training, when you stretch the muscle by moving its insertion and origin away from each other.
The muscle doesn’t hurt when touched lightly, and movement isn’t restricted. Yet there is this slight tugging that lets us know:
THE WORKOUT HAS HAD AN EFFECT
Many of you know what I’m talking about here.
What to Do About Sore Muscles
Now that we understand more about the effects and causes of muscle soreness, we need to clarify what to do if we’ve overdone it during a workout or if a new exercise has taken a bigger toll than expected.
Measures
In any case, it makes sense to immediately reduce the load on the affected muscle group for a short time. At the same time, regenerative measures such as heat therapy, a sauna, or activities that promote blood circulation can aid in recovery.
During training, the intensity of the workout can be slowly increased again after about 2 days. In addition, a thorough warm-up should be performed.
CAUTION
Vigorous massages cause further damage to the muscle. They delay the healing process and should be avoided! Vigorous stretching should also be avoided.
Preventing Severe Muscle Soreness
Consistency
The severity and frequency of muscle soreness decrease with regular, consistent training, as the basic movements eventually become less unfamiliar than they are in the beginner stage.
New Exercises
When starting a new exercise, you should begin with a low intensity. It’s also possible to gradually increase the range of motion—that is, to expand the exercise from an initially limited range of motion to a full range of motion over time. Furthermore, you should not perform new exercises with a pronounced eccentric focus.
Muscle Soreness and Insulin Resistance
As I explained above, there is a connection between muscle soreness and insulin resistance in muscle cells. The microtraumas caused by training reduce the muscle cells’ ability to absorb glucose.
Eccentric training, in particular, leads on the one hand to strong hypertrophy-specific stimuli, but on the other hand also to significant damage to muscular structures.
In this context, consuming large amounts of carbohydrates in conjunction with muscle soreness can lead to elevated blood glucose levels being stored in fat depots, since the insulin sensitivity of fat cells is not reduced by microtrauma to the skeletal muscles.
Study
There is an interesting study on this topic that examines blood glucose levels following eccentric training. Twenty-four hours after performing 6 sets of squats (6 repetitions each) at 80% of 1RM with a 4-second eccentric phase until muscle soreness set in, the participants were given 75 g of glucose mixed with water.
Analysis of blood glucose levels showed that, in contrast to the control group undergoing normal training, the eccentric group exhibited a significantly greater increase.
Conclusion
Heavily eccentric training desensitizes muscle cells, resulting in reduced uptake of ingested glucose into the muscles that were directly trained within 24 hours. Thus, excessive eccentric loading can lead to prolonged recovery and cause blood glucose to be channeled more readily into adipocytes.
There is a direct correlation between the severity of muscle soreness and the degree of insulin resistance in the trained muscle cells!
Interesting
Supplements such as alpha-lipoic acid, chromium, zinc, or cinnamon can increase the insulin sensitivity of muscle cells (as well as fat cells).
Important
There is no risk of diabetes from eccentric training!!
NSAIDs and Muscle Soreness
NSAIDs are nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (e.g., ibuprofen). They are commonly used in the bodybuilding community to prevent muscle soreness after a hard, intense workout.
NSAIDs work by inhibiting the enzyme COX (cyclooxygenase) in muscle cells. When active, this enzyme is responsible for the development of inflammatory processes and muscle pain.
Why is this a drawback?
At first glance, inhibiting inflammatory processes sounds like a good thing, doesn’t it???
The fact is, however, that inflammation is part of the body’s regenerative process. If it is suppressed, muscle protein synthesis decreases, and with it, muscle growth. Studies confirm this.
Taking it before a workout has shown (so far only in endurance sports) a sharp increase in oxidative stress after the workout. It is strongly suspected that these results also apply to strength training.
Blocking inflammatory processes with NSAIDs is, in the case of muscle soreness, a poor and ill-advised option that comes at the expense of recovery.
Summary
Muscle soreness is a condition that occurs particularly in connection with unfamiliar, eccentric exercises or very intense workouts. In principle, muscle soreness is a mechanical defect in the smallest functional structures within our muscles, which triggers specific regeneration processes that manifest as symptoms of muscle soreness.
When evaluating muscle soreness, it’s important to distinguish between the intensity and frequency of the symptoms.
Inflicting chronic and extreme microtrauma—which manifests as severe muscle soreness—is not only pointless but also counterproductive, since it not only leads to scarring in the muscle but also impairs the muscle cells’ sensitivity to insulin. Mild muscle soreness without significant pain, on the other hand, can be viewed as positive based on personal experience.
If you’re dealing with acute muscle soreness, you should under no circumstances resume intense eccentric training the very next day. The other extreme—waiting for the muscle soreness to subside completely before training again—is also unnecessary. After two days of rest and limited activity, you can resume training even if symptoms persist.
Muscle soreness is something that the smart bodybuilder uses to gauge the intensity of their own training.
Starting today, you’re one of those smart bodybuilders!
With that in mind, I send my best wishes to all our readers.

Best regards,
Yours
Holger Gugg
www.body-coaches.de