Some Thoughts on Your Competition Diet – Part 2

10 Min

Die Wochen 15 bis 8 vor dem Wettkampf: Lebensmittelauswahl, Sättigungs-Index, Makros, Nutrition-Timing und die Frage, ob Cheating in der Wettkampfdiät sinnvoll ist.

Gute Protein- und Fettquellen für die WettkampfdiätIn Part 1, I shared a few critical thoughts with you about starting a competition diet. This series is explicitly titled “Competition Diet” rather than “Competition Preparation,” since competition preparation involves quite a few other tasks that I won’t be covering here today. If you’d like a good overview of the entire topic of competition preparation, you’ll find it in my article from the September 2015 issue of Muscle&Fitness, which I’ve posted for you HERE.

In Part 1, we laid the groundwork for your preparation, and you received some important information on how to structure the first few weeks. Today, we’ll focus on Phase 2—the final 15 to 8 weeks leading up to your competition. We’ll discuss suitable foods, the right macronutrient distribution, and the question of whether you can—or even should—“cheat” while on a competition diet.

 

15 to 8 Weeks Before D-Day

The “good” ones among you who’ve already done your homework during the build-up phase may have even been able to skip Phase 1 entirely. However, virtually every competition diet will need to last around 15 to at least 12 weeks, so this is where it gets interesting for all active athletes.

Food Selection

What has been achieved so far—primarily through a calorie deficit and likely a few structured cardio sessions—now requires somewhat stricter guidelines. It’s always important to look ahead and, in addition to the actual diet goal, consider how certain restrictions and changes in food choices will affect the athlete. Studies such as those by Rolls et al. (12) or Yeoman et al. (13) confirm what every active athlete can attest to from personal experience: “As soon as you’re not allowed to have something, that’s exactly what you want most.” It seems to be deeply ingrained in the human psyche, and without exception, everyone will have to grapple with this to a greater or lesser extent over the course of the next 15 weeks.

Ketogenic Diet?

From this perspective, the question arises in practice regarding the necessity and even the wisdom of a competition diet based on ketogenic guidelines. In the vast majority of cases, better results aren’t to be expected; the risk of muscle loss increases as the diet progresses—especially for natural athletes—and the mental strain of deprivation (as described above) is virtually unbearable for athletes who have had no prior experience with the ketogenic diet. They will completely lose their way at the first opportunity—such as on their first permitted “cheat day”—and will no longer be able to control themselves—BELIEVE THAT!

Conclusion

The same rule applies during this phase of the diet: DON’T CUT BACK ON FOOD TOO QUICKLY!

Satiety Index / Fullness Factor

The Satiety Index is a helpful tool for any preparation. Do you remember my very detailed post on managing hunger and satiety? The Satiety Index was the topic in Part 1.
Here’s the key paragraph again that illustrates its potential:

Particularly interesting for practical application is a concept known as the Fullness Factor (Satiety Index). In 1995, Holt et al. investigated whether there are differences in the perceived feeling of fullness caused by different foods. To this end, they administered a total of 38 different foods to test subjects and then surveyed them on their satiety levels compared to the reference food, white bread. As it turned out, the foods that are most filling are those that weigh the most—regardless of their caloric content. However, there were also correlations with other food properties, which is why the approach based solely on food volume—as mentioned above in the theory of the Fullness Factor—should not be understood as the sole indicator of short-term satiety. After reviewing numerous studies on the topic of satiety, a formula for determining the so-called “Fullness Factor” (FF) has ultimately emerged.

You can see HERE which foods were tested and have a particularly high Fullness Factor:

Conclusion

Foods provide a pleasant, satiating feeling to varying degrees. Take advantage of this property by making targeted food choices.

Macros

At this stage of the diet, it’s important to get the basics right. This includes, first and foremost, ensuring an adequate intake of protein within the HBN-compliant range of 2.5 g per kilogram of body weight or target weight. For athletes preparing naturally, this is all that’s necessary—and more isn’t needed. Studies by Hall et al. (16) and Elia et al. (17) support a further increase only during the final phase of preparation. That is, when body fat percentage is already very low. I offer an alternative approach to maintaining optimal protein turnover with my new method of using HBN EAA CODE. Here, too, protein requirements are first determined using the guideline mentioned above, but a portion of that is replaced by the aforementioned EAA product.

Advantages:

  • Protein synthesis can be maximized thanks to the administration of the perfect EAA matrix in the correct amount
  • Nitrogen waste and, consequently, the strain on the urea cycle are reduced
  • Reduced acid load (keyword: pH value)
  • The calories freed up can serve as an additional calorie deficit or be allocated to the remaining two macronutrients as desired

I’ve summarized the entire topic of HBN EAA CODE for you HERE.

It cannot be emphasized enough—every macronutrient has its place, no matter what phase you’re in. It’s interesting to note in this context that cholesterol (14) and saturated fatty acids (15), in particular, are beneficial for maintaining lean body mass and should not be intentionally minimized! On the other hand, there are also studies that demonstrate a certain necessity for moderate amounts of carbohydrates to maintain performance levels and lean body mass (18, 19).

HBN Signatured Series EAA-Code

Conclusion

No macronutrient is “bad,” let alone unnecessary. The use of essential amino acids in the perfect balance holds great potential, particularly in a competition diet.

Nutrition Timing

To get this out of the way—while my nutritional concept, HBN (Human-Based Nutrition), criticizes some common fasting models, it does not entirely rule out the inclusion of fasting windows. In fact, especially during competition preparation, it can be beneficial to schedule a fasting window for a few hours each day, the timing of which should be adjusted as the diet progresses—particularly with regard to protein intake (EAA intake)—despite the amino acid pool! On the one hand, fasting allows for a few larger, truly satisfying meals; on the other hand, the fasting period between meals is easier to manage when blood sugar can be maintained at a constant level through the interplay of insulin and glucagon, completely unaffected by food.
In my view, the practice of “breakfast skipping”—that is, skipping breakfast—remains ill-advised. This can be justified in part by the cells’ excellent (insulin-sparing) ability to absorb nutrients, particularly in the morning hours, which has been demonstrated in numerous studies through high insulin sensitivity (20). The big question regarding breakfast, then, is not “whether” to eat it, but “how.” Here, both athletes and the average person must finally realize that breakfast should NOT be high in carbohydrates, but rather a moderate-protein, low-carbohydrate, and high-fiber option (21).
Finally, regarding nutrition timing, there’s still a need to address post-workout nutrition—and in particular, the merits of consuming high-glycemic-load (HGL) carbs after a workout. The “pro” camp argues that this has a positive effect on glycogen resynthesis and thus on a crucial part of the recovery process (22). Also from the “pro” camp comes the theory that insulin (triggered by the consumption of HGL carbs) has an inhibitory effect on protein breakdown and, in the presence of amino acids, also promotes protein synthesis—albeit not to the same significant extent as its role in inhibiting breakdown (23). While Pro Argument 1 remains valid and certainly plays a greater role, especially in a nutrient-deprived state, a recent meta-analysis by Abdula et al. (24) shows that large amounts of insulin are not required for the aforementioned influence on protein metabolism. This raises the question of to what extent the insulinogenic effect of amino acids may already be sufficient to mediate the full insulin effect. The bottom line is that we benefit from consuming protein (EAAs are sufficient!!) after exercise to positively influence protein metabolism. Carbohydrates primarily serve to accelerate glycogen resynthesis, while there is still no complete consensus on the actual effects resulting from a carbohydrate-induced rise in insulin. Particularly in the context of a competition diet, the intake of protein (EAAs) and carbohydrates continues to be recommended!

Conclusion

No matter how you choose to structure your competition diet, breakfast and targeted post-workout nutrition should be fixed meals!

Cheating / Refeed

Taking into account all physiological as well as psychological and metabolic aspects of competition preparation, “cheating” is indeed an extremely effective tool.

Note
: Spare me the nitpicking over differences in the definitions of “cheating” and “refeed.” What’s meant here is unscheduled eating for a specific period of time and for a specific purpose—whether I call it “cheating” or “refeed”—thanks, guys!

Hellburner Carb Smasher

Cheating can be incredibly important for mental resilience. The prospect of something you’re supposed to strictly avoid during a competition diet boosts motivation and helps you stick with it. Athletes who manage their own training—but especially coaches—should be aware of the power of this tool.

The extent to which “cheating” makes sense from a physiological and metabolic standpoint depends on several factors:

  • Genetics
  • Duration of the diet
  • Calorie deficit
  • Body fat percentage

You’ve already read about all these factors in my previous posts, specifically in connection with the most dominant of all satiety hormones: leptin. Leptin is so important for every competitive athlete because it plays a major role in regulating the body—not only metabolically but also mentally. Lower leptin levels inevitably mean (25):

  • Greater hunger
  • Reduced fatty acid oxidation
  • Reduced lipolysis (adipose tissue and liver)
  • Increased lipogenesis (adipose tissue and liver)
  • Increased insulin secretion
  • Increased cortisol secretion
  • Decreased production of thyroid hormone
  • Reduced metabolic rate

Anyone who understands leptin’s evolutionary role can see why these specific changes occur. It’s a matter of sheer survival! Too few calories combined with too little body fat—and perhaps even a poor genetic predisposition (set-point theory)—prompt the body to reduce energy expenditure and switch fully into “store and conserve” mode. You can read about the overall effects this mechanism can have during a diet in my article (26). Much of this stems from the overarching influence of leptin. In Part 3 of my post on hunger and satiety (27), you can see just how strongly leptin influences the entire orexic network, which is why this particular signaling molecule deserves the utmost attention.
The good news is that leptin can be influenced relatively quickly and in the short term. Even dietary adjustments made within a single day can bring leptin levels back to their baseline (25). So while the “usual” one “cheat day” certainly has some effect, other suggestions call for taking 3 to even 5 consecutive cheat days, which (if planned correctly) will result in a significant weight gain but not in a major increase in fat mass (MacDonald mentions up to 100g!!).

Note
: If you’re planning 3 to 5 cheat days, you should first consider whether you can really afford to take that much time off!

Gute Protein- und Fettquellen für die Wettkampfdiät

When planned correctly, however, the right calorie intake also requires the right balance of macronutrients. Here are the basic rules for a cheat day:

  • High-calorie
  • Very low fat
  • Moderate protein
  • High-carb

Conclusion

A clear YES to strategic “cheating,” from both psychological and physiological-metabolic-hormonal perspectives.

Summary

I think in Part 2 I was able to debunk one or two myths in the scene. The psychological impact that food has on us is especially often overlooked during a competition diet. Coaches and trainers focus on “eating what works.” The fact that this makes things unnecessarily difficult for athletes is often overlooked. Despite all due caution, specific guidelines must still be established and implemented right now.

Part 3 will conclude by focusing on the truly critical phase: Weeks 8 through 1 and, of course, D-Day. So stay tuned

 

 

Holger GuggBest regards,

Holger Gugg

www.body-coaches.de

 

 

 

 

 

 

Sources

  • (12) http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0031938481900147
  • (13) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15384315
  • (14) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17921432
  • (15) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9029197
  • (16) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17848938
  • (17) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10574520
  • (18) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21558571
  • (19) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19927027
  • (20) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27492405
  • (21) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27184285
  • (22) http://www.jssm.org/vol3/n3/3/v3n3-3pdf.pdf?hc_location=ufi
  • (23) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26404065
  • (24) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26404065
  • (25) https://www.peak.ag/de/classic/peak-blog/was-macht-wirklich-satt-teil-2-sattheit
  • (26) https://www.peak.ag/de/classic/peak-blog/was-passiert-wirklich-mit-dem-stoffwechsel-wenn-wir-auf-diaet-sind
  • (27) https://www.peak.ag/de/classic/peak-blog/was-macht-wirklich-satt-teil-3-orexisches-netzwerk-und-die-praxis

Image source: Dani Vincek/Fotolia.com